7
1410 Balfour St, Fenwick, ON L0S 1C0, Canada
Pelham, Ontario L0S 1C0
+19058921289

The staff were super welcoming, friendly, and helpful. They had a great variety of pies and other sweets. The Pie and treats I got today were very fresh

Nice little bakery in the country they have a wide selection of frozen dinners as well as some nice treats and pies Give them a try support local small business!

Amazing little bakery. Local as it comes, it's such a hole in the wall that if you don't see the driveway the first time, you'll go right past it. The pastries are to die for!

Took my mom to visit (we had heard good things) & we were not disappointed!!. We ordered their portugese tarts & their homemade flakies (which they made for us fresh on the spot, my mom was blown away by this touch) & it was all amazing. I have no notes, everything was top shelf. We will definitely be back to try some of the various pies on offer, both the savoury & sweet, 100% worth the drive, highly recommend these lovely folks & their very tasty nibbles ❤️

I’ve had their items at a few events and everything is absolutely delicious!! The flakies are divine! I live no where near their location so I was thrilled when my kid came to visit and brought me my favourite Portuguese tarts! Best ones I’ve ever had!

Great place for homemade pies of both the sweet or savoury type. We ordered over $80.00 worth of product and do say the taste is authentic homemade of ALL products! Chicken pot pie is out of this world. The only turn off is their debit machine asks for a tip which is unwarranted and part of everyone trying to join the tip culture. Raise the product price if you want more money as I will not subsidize through a tip. May not return because of this. Otherwise food is all awesome!

Our first time visiting your store today. 1000% delicious. My daughter and I both had the Southwestern wrap combo. Super duper value for money and "fantastically delicious"....if that is a saying LOL. Very hearty and tasty. We shared The Long John eclair, fantastic. After our tulip farm visit, we came back to buy some pies home. Your blueberry pie is one of the best I've ever tasted, not too sweet, awesome crumble, even more awesome shortcrust, not to mention that blueberry filling. (I work in the food industry so have discerning taste ) We are baking 2 small pies and the Taco Cheeseburger macaroni now for a late dinner for the rest of the fam. Also bought 6 mini tarts for dessert. If it was a cooler day, we would have tried the soup too. Well done! What a hidden gem. As well, staff members were super nice. It would be even more perfect if we can have a couple more picnic tables for eating outside.

Show Map

Fenwick Pie Co. — Bakery in Pelham

We are glad to greet you!

Fenwick Pie Co.

Bakery at 1410 Balfour St, Fenwick, ON L0S 1C0, Canada. Here you will find detailed information about Fenwick Pie Co.: address, phone, fax, opening hours, customer reviews, photos, directions and more.

Opening hours

  • Sunday
    Closed
  • Monday
    Closed
  • Tuesday
    10 AM–5 PM
  • Wednesday
    10 AM–5 PM
  • Thursday
    9 AM–5 PM
  • Friday
    9 AM–5 PM
  • Saturday
    10 AM–5 PM

Rating

5
/
5
Based on 7 reviews

Contacts

Categories:
State:
Ontario
Address:
1410 Balfour St, Fenwick, ON L0S 1C0, Canada.
City:
Pelham
Phone:
Postcode:
L0S 1C0

About Fenwick Pie Co.

Fenwick Pie Co. is a Canadian Bakery based in Pelham, Ontario. Fenwick Pie Co. is located at 1410 Balfour St, Fenwick, ON L0S 1C0, Canada.


Please contact with Fenwick Pie Co. using information above: Address, Phone number, Fax, Postal code, Website address, E-mail, Facebook. Find Fenwick Pie Co. opening hours and driving directions or map. Find real customer reviews and ratings or write your own review.

Are you the owner?
You can make a change to the page:
Edit this page

ALL reviews about Fenwick Pie Co.

  • Linda Ramdhar
    Added 2025.11.29
    The staff were super welcoming, friendly, and helpful. They had a great variety of pies and other sweets. The Pie and treats I got today were very fresh
  • David Rienties
    Added 2025.05.01
    Nice little bakery in the country they have a wide selection of frozen dinners as well as some nice treats and pies Give them a try support local small business!
  • Daniel Casket
    Added 2024.12.06
    Amazing little bakery. Local as it comes, it's such a hole in the wall that if you don't see the driveway the first time, you'll go right past it. The pastries are to die for!
  • Vanessa K
    Added 2024.10.26
    Took my mom to visit (we had heard good things) & we were not disappointed!!. We ordered their portugese tarts & their homemade flakies (which they made for us fresh on the spot, my mom was blown away by this touch) & it was all amazing. I have no notes, everything was top shelf. We will definitely be back to try some of the various pies on offer, both the savoury & sweet, 100% worth the drive, highly recommend these lovely folks & their very tasty nibbles ❤️
  • Maryanne Mcfadden
    Added 2024.09.28
    I’ve had their items at a few events and everything is absolutely delicious!! The flakies are divine! I live no where near their location so I was thrilled when my kid came to visit and brought me my favourite Portuguese tarts! Best ones I’ve ever had!
  • Craig Logan
    Added 2024.06.30
    Great place for homemade pies of both the sweet or savoury type. We ordered over $80.00 worth of product and do say the taste is authentic homemade of ALL products! Chicken pot pie is out of this world. The only turn off is their debit machine asks for a tip which is unwarranted and part of everyone trying to join the tip culture. Raise the product price if you want more money as I will not subsidize through a tip. May not return because of this. Otherwise food is all awesome!
  • By owner
    Added 2024.08.29
    Thanks for the review Craig! We're glad you loved everything! When we first set up our payment system, we decided to omit the tip option. However, after receiving numerous inquiries about why it wasn't available, we added it. Tips are never expected but are always appreciated by our staff.
  • Winnie Chiu
    Added 2023.05.13
    Our first time visiting your store today. 1000% delicious. My daughter and I both had the Southwestern wrap combo. Super duper value for money and "fantastically delicious"....if that is a saying LOL. Very hearty and tasty. We shared The Long John eclair, fantastic. After our tulip farm visit, we came back to buy some pies home. Your blueberry pie is one of the best I've ever tasted, not too sweet, awesome crumble, even more awesome shortcrust, not to mention that blueberry filling. (I work in the food industry so have discerning taste ) We are baking 2 small pies and the Taco Cheeseburger macaroni now for a late dinner for the rest of the fam. Also bought 6 mini tarts for dessert. If it was a cooler day, we would have tried the soup too. Well done! What a hidden gem. As well, staff members were super nice. It would be even more perfect if we can have a couple more picnic tables for eating outside.
  • By owner
    Added 2023.05.13
    We are working on getting more tables! Thank you so much for the kind words we truly appreciate it!
Leave your own review about Fenwick Pie Co.:
Add a review

You Might Also Consider

The Baking Bar
Bakery in Ontario
7 reviews
11 Hwy 20 W, Fonthill, ON L0S 1E3, Canada.